Sustainable Trade and Innovation Centre (STIC)
[last updated August 29, 2005 12:00 AM]

Shortcuts:

General Information
Partnership website(s)
Expected Timeframe
Pre 2002 - December Open Ended
Partners
Governments:
    Major Groups:
    • European Partners for the Environment (Belgium)
    • Internat. Inst. for Sustainable Development (Canada)
    • Eco-tex Institute (Germany)
    • Ecoperation-Netherlands (Netherlands)
    • Internat. Institute for Environment and Devt (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland)
    UN System:
    • United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) (Switzerland)
    • United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) (United States of America)
    Other intergovernmental organizations:
    • Commonwealth Science Council (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland)
    Other:
    • Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (South Africa)
     
    Thematic Focus
    Primary Themes:
    • Sustainable development in a globalizing world
    Secondary Themes:
    • Changing unsustainable patterns of consumption and production
    Geographic Coverage
    Geographic Scope: Global
    Country(ies) where the partnership is being implemented:
    Bangladesh, Belgium, Benin, Bhutan, Brazil, Cambodia, China, Costa Rica, European Community, India, Jamaica, Mauritius, Netherlands, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Viet Nam
    National Focal Points
    This partnership has not made any contact with the national focal points for sustainable development in the countries involved
    Goals and Objectives
    Summary of the partnership's goals and objectives
    Globally, no institution is mandated to support developing countries respond to this challenge. The scoping study found that an array of multilateral, national, NGO and business initiatives currently exist - in many cases delivering useful results. But these are often small-scale, limited in terms of sectoral scope or types of participants. To deliver genuine benefits to developing country exporters, the study concluded that a dedicated organisation is required that brings together four key attributes:
    - practical experience with export promotion;
    - expertise in sustainability issues;
    - technical competence in innovation; and, crucially
    - developing country leadership.
    The Sustainable Trade and Innovation Centre aims to fill this gap. The proposed goal of STIC is to enable developing country exporters to respond, anticipate and ultimately shape the environmental and social dimensions of the market, thereby capturing a greater share of the value-added of trade. This can be achieved in three main ways:
    i. information exchange
    ii. promoting innovation and strengthening skills
    iii. brokering solutions
    i. Information Exchange
    Practical experience has shown that inadequate information is often a major constraint to both developing country producers and the buyers in developed countries. Very often developing country producers lack information on the multitude of standards and regulations that exist in export markets. This is often accompanied by a lack of knowledge and know how on technological and managerial solutions. On the part of the North too there is inadequate information and understanding, not only of the pressures facing businesses operating in the South, but also of the potential for Southern businesses to meet environmental and social challenges.
    Targets and Progress
    Partnership targets
    The feasibility study for the establishment of STIC (presently ongoing) will be completed by July 2002. The specific aims of the feasibility project are to:
    - Finalise aims and objectives of STIC
    - Design the Centre's governance and decision-making structures;
    - Identify a suitable location of the secretariat of the Centre;
    - Present a possible work programme and working method;
    - Draft a business plan, including donor support;
    - Generate political support for the concept.
    The outcome of the feasibility project could then be presented at
    * the WSSD Ministerial Prepcom Meeting in Indonesia (May 2002)
    * the Third European Conference preparing the WSSD (June 20-21, 2002), and
    * the WSSD.
    The Centre itself is foreseen to be established within a year of the completion of the feasibility study.
    Progress against targets
    The initiative has already been launched and the Sustainable Trade and Innovation Centre will formally be launched by October 2003.

    Two steering group meetings have been held since WSSD. Additional funds have been obtained from the Dutch Ministry of Physical Planning and Housing which has enabled the start of operational activities. A detailed work plan has been prepared and is being implemented.

    All partners have committed fully to the process and we are in the process of formalising partnerships with developing country businesses and NGOs.
    Capacity-Building and Technology Transfer
    Arrangements for Capacity-Building and Technology Transfer
    • Human resources development/training
    • Education/building awareness
    • Technology transfer/exchange
    STIC's objectives include the provision of information as well as capacity building and innovation. The challenge is to ensure that the experience of these market leaders is replicated on an industry wide basis. STIC will aim to act as a hub for building such capabilities in developing countries. Examples of the type of activities STIC could undertake include: * Foresighting: strengthening the capabilities of producers to undertake technological foresighting. This may be done, for example, by adapting the CSC's existing work on foresighting to emerging global requirements for sustainability; * Norms and standards: building the technical and managerial capacity to conform with mutually agreed upon norms and standards; * Tools and techniques: training producers on tools and techniques such as the Integrated Product Policy, life cycle analysis, Eco-Design etc., as well as co-designing management and reporting systems for SME's; * Applied research: Making links with existing research institutes, including CSIRs in various countries, in the application of technical solutions for sustainability and productivity gains. One example of a capacity building activity led by the Commonwealth Science Council is the support provided by way of training in eco design to electronic component manufacturers in India in meeting the forthcoming (2008) EU legislation on Wastes from Electronics and Electronic Equipment (WEEE). This has enabled Indian manufacturers not only to effect technological changes for redesign, but also to improve management and interaction with agents along their supply chain, resulting in environmental and productivity gains. It is envisaged that STIC will use existing networks such as the Councils for Scientific and Industrial Research in various countries, the Commonwealth Science Council, institutes of technology and applied research, as well relevant UN agencies as avenues for dissemination and transfer of technology.
    Relationship to International Agreements on Sustainable Development
    How the partnership contributes to the implementation of Agenda 21, the Programme for the Further Implementation of Agenda 21, and the Johannesburg Plan of Implementation
    Relationship to Agenda 21:
    STIC will directly address the goals of Agenda 21 as they relate to the following:
    -Promotion of sustainable development through trade.
    -Making trade and environment mutually supportive.
    -Combating poverty and improving social justice in the workplace.
    -Integrating environment and development at the management level.
    -Conservation and management of resources for development (especially in the forestry, agri-food and fisheries).
    -Strengthening the role of workers, business and industry and the scientific and technological community.
    -Transfer of environmentally sound technology, cooperation and capacity building.
    -Promoting training
    -Improving availability of information.
    Relationship to the UN Millennium Declaration:
    STIC conforms with the Values and Principles of the UN Millennium Declaration, and, in particular with following clauses related to Development and Poverty Eradication as well as Protection of the Environment:
    -Transparency in trading systems
    -Addressing the special needs of least developed countries
    -Developing strong partnerships with the private sector and civil society in pursuit if development
    -Reaffirming support for Agenda 21 Relevant Sections of Agenda 21
    Combating poverty; Integrating environment and development in decision-making; Combating deforestation; Promoting sustainable agriculture and rural development; Protection of the oceans, all kinds of seas, including enclosed and semi-enclosed seas, and coastal areas and the protection, rational use and development of their living resources; Strengthening the role of workers and their trade unions; Transfer of environmentally sound technology, cooperation and capacity-building; Promoting education, public awareness and training; Information for decision-making
    Relevant Sections of the Programme for the Further Implementation of Agenda 21
    Integration of economic, social and environmental objectives; Sectors and issues; Means of implementation
    Relevant Sections of the Johannesburg Plan of Implementation
    Poverty eradication ; Protection and managing the natural resource base of economic and social development ; Sustainable development in a globalizing world ; Means of implementation
    Coordination and Implementation
    Coordination Mechanism of the Partnership
    Based on a sectoral analysis of the textile, forestry, food and tourism industry, the feasibility study (funded by the CSC and the European Commission's DG Trade) is currently elaborating the governance, structure and financing options for STIC. However some preliminary thoughts on the coordination and implementation mechanisms are presented below.
    Core secretariat: STIC should have a lean core secretariat manned by 3-5 persons with the ability to cut across different sectors and industries. The Head quarter/Secretariat should maintain an analytical and evaluation function with links to research capacity in other institutions. It would also be responsible for the core functions of STIC such as the publication of a yearbook on STIC's activities, modelled on a sectoral basis, including information on:
    * market trends and opportunities, standards and regulations for environmental, labour and ethical practices in importing markets;
    * production conditions and constraints faced by producers in developing countries, costs and procedures for certification;
    * case studies promoting and highlighting good practice of developing country producers that have penetrated and seized market opportunities in the North.
    Network: STIC should have a decentralised set up with functional nodes in different countries and regions-it should be a 'bottom heavy' network with private institutions and NGOs at the country/regional acting as nodes. The national nodes should have sectoral competence and technical expertise in the environmental and social aspects of production and trade, as well as in export promotion, trade facilitation and information dissemination.
    Governing Council: STIC should have a governing council made up of developing and developed country representatives from relevant organisations such as the United Nations, industry associations, NGOs, donor agencies etc. with clear leadership from developing countries.
    Arrangements for monitoring of progress will include:
    -Governing Board
    -Advisory Board
    -Quarterly internal progress reports
    -Public Annual Report on STIC's activities
    -Regular Newsletters
    Implementation Mechanism of the Partnership
    On the economic front STIC will result in increased exports from developing to OECD countries of goods and services that are produced in an environmentally sound and socially equitable manner.
    STIC will facilitate and result in improved social and environmental performance of the manufacturing industry in developing countries, as well as buyers and retailers in developed countries.
    STIC will result in better governance and increased participation of Southern businesses in the setting of voluntary standards, codes of conduct and regulations relating to environmental and social issues.
    The functioning of STIC will be based on networking with existing initiatives at the global and regional level. The feasibility study will elaborate on these initiatives.
    The Centre should work with a variety of projects and partners depending on the functions it undertakes. STIC's functions should evolve on a gradual basis and this will determine the nature and number of partners and projects. It is envisaged that STIC will be involved in two types of activities:
    * projects that STIC will run on its own (e.g. technical innovation, training, dialogues on co-evolution of standards)
    * STIC as a zone of learning i.e. dissemination of knowledge and projects as well as lessons learned from other related initiatives including peer review of other projects.
    Resources
    Funding Currently Available
    Amount in US$: 411189
    Source(s): Government
    We have obtained Euros 350,000 from the Dutch government to kick start the process and will be looking for additional funding. Funding for the feasibility study has been obtained from the Commonwealth Science Council and the European Union (DG Trade), DANIDA and the French Ministry for the Environment.
    Non-financial resources available
    Type(s):
    Source(s):
    Funding Sought
    Required Amount in US$: not specified
    Source(s) already approached: 2. Funding for the establishment of STIC and its operations will necessarily have to come from a combination of sources:
    -core funding: from governments/ foundations
    -payment for services rendered: this may require initial subsidies to enable take off e.g. for information provision. Also, they could be devised on a cost basis in ways that are affordable for developing country producers.
    -membership fees.
    Note: the feasibility study will recommend a financing structure and a business plan for STIC.
    Non-financial resources sought
    Requirement(s):
    Source(s) approached and details:
    Additional Information
    Additional Relevant Information
    BACKGROUND - THE NEED FOR STIC
    Exporters from developing countries are facing mounting pressures to integrate environmental and social factors into their export strategies. While some of this is prompted by regulatory demands (notably from the EU), the main drivers are business requirements from international buyers and a growing demand from the end consumer for products that demonstrate environmental and social responsibility. Environmental, and increasingly social, factors are now routinely incorporated into supplier contracts across a range of sectors. New trade opportunities have resulted for some producers.
    But many exporters have experienced difficulties responding to these demands, incurring extra costs at a time when global competition is constantly eroding returns to the producer. Although higher standards are sometimes associated with premium prices in export markets, more often they are simply an 'entry ticket' -- an added burden rather than a source of competitive advantage. These concerns are being heightened by the mounting complexity of environmental and social aspects of international trade, with an array of often incompatible measures, from company-specific codes of conduct through regional initiatives to global systems of certification.
    While the motivation behind these market-driven measures to improve the environment may be genuine, the manner in which they have been implemented leaves much to be desired. In particular:
    * They lack transparency - with little or no involvement of developing country producers in setting the standards;
    * They fail to consider questions of equity - and the way in which the costs of improving environmental and social performance are distributed along the supply chain; and
    * They neglect the need to make the links between environmental measures and developing country capacity for innovation - essential if environmental upgrading is to generate lasting productivity and gains to value-added.
    The result is considerable frustration in the marketplace and fears that these voluntary market-based environmental requirements will simply hamper export prospects ('green protectionism'). On the part of the North, there is still widespread distrust of the South and its capacity to move towards sustainable production and trade. A new generation of enterprises has come to the fore in many developing countries committed and capable of achieving world-class standards in quality, the environment and social matters. However, media reports, which inform public opinion and NGO campaigns, tend to focus exclusively on poor performers where bad practice undoubtedly still exists.
    If these market pressures are to lead to genuinely sustainable development - a pressing theme in the run-up to the Johannesburg Summit - then additional measures are required to give developing country exporters both the capacity and the connections to shape these requirements to their advantage.
    There is therefore a definite need for greater information exchange. There are a number of existing initiatives to learn from. Examples include:
    - Global initiatives: The International Trade Centre (ITC) supports information networks in developing economies, such as World Tr@de Net and Capacity building and networking for business information services (CAPNET/BIS);
    - Regional initiatives: The Sustainable Markets Intelligence Service (SMIS) is being set up by the Latin American Centre for Competitiveness and Sustainable Development in Costa Rica to provide information on market trends and opportunities to Latin American firms to allow them to orient their products and processes towards high value markets for environmentally and socially preferable products.
    - Donor supported initiatives: the Dutch Ecooperation initiative has set up an electronic One World Market to facilitate trade in sustainable products between the Netherlands and selected African countries, while GTZ's Protrade programme has established a 'Green Trade Net' database for organic products from developing countries.
    Two key problems have confronted these information initiatives. First, there is often inadequate national network leadership in participating countries. Second, experience has shown that in many countries, a purely electronic information dissemination network is inappropriate and must be accompanied by more traditional information dissemination activities.
    There is also a need to link up existing information exchange activities. STIC will aim to provide comprehensive and coordinated information dissemination, with the active support of existing networks. It will do this through various media: websites, workshops, seminars, and briefings. At the sectoral level, for example, STIC will work together with business organisations such as the International Apparel Federation in disseminating information to the textile and clothing producers in developing countries and retailers in developed countries.
    ii. Promoting innovation and strengthening skills
    Moving to sustainable patterns of production and trade requires investments of time, commitment and finance, and this means the development of new support mechanisms for producers and other agents. Experience has shown that it is the innovative businesses, those that have introduced changes in product design as well as in management practices, that have been able to seize the opportunity, increasing exports of sustainable products and making profits in the bargain.
    iii. Brokering solutions
    One of the major obstacles facing developing country producers is a lack of input into the plethora of trade related environmental and social standard setting initiatives. Dialogue along the value chain needs to be stimulated to generate fair, feasible and lasting solutions. This dialogue needs to bring three sets of stakeholders to the table: business representatives, such as buyers and suppliers; regulatory and standard setting authorities; and civil society representatives. At present no organisation is engaged in such activities in a dedicated and singular manner with developing countries entrepreneurs as the main target beneficiaries

    Two particular priorities for STIC could be:
    * Voicing the concerns of developing country producers in implementing existing environmental and social standards imposed by export markets, and, working together with standard setters to ensure that these concerns are taken in to consideration;
    * Co-designing mutually agreed upon standards and codes through dialogues between different stakeholder groups. Professional and well-facilitated dialogues may be organized on sectoral and geographical lines. They should bring together consumer groups, industry, buyers, financial institutions, governments, NGOs, researchers from the North and South. Preparations for such dialogues would involve an analysis of:
    o the implications of EU and other Northern requirements for Southern producers;
    o the possibilities and ways forward for elaborating a mutually agreed upon minimum code of conduct for particular sectors;
    o the requirements for implementing such a code, including the tools and techniques for: managing sustainable supply chains; implementing social accountability improvements; and applying eco-efficient solutions.


    Links:
    Some examples of potential partners/linkages are given below:
    - Global initiatives: UNCTAD's Biotrade Initiative for increasing market access for biodiversity products from developing countries; The International Trade Centre (ITC) information networks in developing economies, such as World Tr@de Net and Capacity building and networking for business information services (CAPNET/BIS);
    - Regional initiatives: The Sustainable Markets Intelligence Service (SMIS) being set up by the Latin American Centre for Competitiveness and Sustainable Development in Costa Rica to provide information on market trends and opportunities to Latin American firms to allow them to orient their products and processes towards high value markets for environmentally and socially preferable products.
    - Donor supported initiatives: the Dutch Ecooperation initiative to facilitate trade in sustainable products between the Netherlands and selected African countries; GTZ's Protrade programme and 'Green Trade Net' database for organic products from developing countries.